LSAT Question Explanation

PT 158, Section 2, Question 10

Identify the Flaw

Argument structure

Conclusion

Swahili culture was influenced by Oromo culture.

Evidence

The Swahili built tombs with specific architectural features. Similar structures are also found among the Oromo people. Similar structures are not found among any other civilizations that the Swahili communicated with.

Explanation

Ok, so both the Swahili and Oromo had these similar structures. But how do we know the Swahili were influenced by the Oromo? Couldn't the Swahili have built the tombs first and then influenced the Oromo? The author gives us no reason to think that their conclusion is better than the clear alternative, that the Oromo were influenced by the Swahili.

Also, the two cultures could have come up with the building styles independently.

Answer choices

(A)

This doesn't really matter. The shared architectural features could still indicate influence, even if the buildings were used differently.

(B)

This answer choice isn't descriptively accurate. The stimulus didn't tell us which culture built the buildings first.

(C)

This answer choice indicates that the conclusion could have been much stronger, which is not true of the stimulus. The flaw was concluding one explanation when there are others that are also reasonable.

(D)

The stimulus actually says that no other civilization that the Swahili had contact with built in this style. So even if there's a third civilization that did this, it doesn't undermine the conclusion. That third civilization either wouldn't have had contact with either the Swahili or Oromo, making them irrelevant to the argument, or they would have had contact with only the Oromo, in which case the conclusion would still be reasonable.

(E) ✓

This is the problem with the argument. Based on the premises, it seems reasonable that the Swahili could have influenced the Oromo, but the author doesn't address this and just says it was the other way around.