LSAT Question Explanation
PT 158, Section 2, Question 9
Identify the RoleArgument structure
A successful legal system prohibits only those few behaviors that citizens find absolutely intolerable.
A law should deter actions by threatening punishment. The threat only works if people think they are likely to be punished. If there are more prohibited actions, people are less likely to be punished.
Explanation
Basically this argument is saying that we shouldn't ban too many things because people won't feel as deterred. Rather, we should only ban the worst behaviors, making it more likely that people will be punished for those behaviors, which would best deter people from committing those most intolerable acts.
The question asks us what role the first sentence plays. The first three sentences are all premises that support the conclusion.
Answer choices
This gets the conclusion wrong. The conclusion is that we should only ban the most intolerable behaviors.
No. The sentence we're asked about in the question stem is a premise/evidence.
This is accurate. The author uses this statement as the basis for their reasoning.
No, there is no support for the first sentence.
No, the first sentence works with the other premises to support the conclusion. It isn't discredited/refuted by the argument.