LSAT Question Explanation
PT 158, Section 2, Question 11
Necessary AssumptionArgument structure
The chorus in a play is not equivalent to the narrator in a novel.
The chorus in a play is sometimes inconsistent with the rest of the information in the play.
Explanation
So the conclusion is that a play's chorus and a novel's narrator are not the same. The evidence is that a play's chorus can be inconsistent with the rest of the play. So it seems they're assuming that a novel's narrator is always consistent with the rest of the information in the novel.
Answer choices
This seems tempting at first glance, but technically being deceptive is different than presenting inconsistent information. So it doesn't quite match our prediction.
This is not relevant, we don't care if plays sometimes need narrators. We're just comparing the chorus of a play with the narrator of a novel.
We don't need the chorus to present necessary information. We're just trying to show that the chorus of a play is different from the narrator of a novel on the basis of if they present information consistent with the rest of the work.
Yes, this needs to be true to say that the chorus of a play and the narrator of a novel are different. The stimulus told us that the chorus can be inconsistent, this answer choice tells us that the narrator can not be inconsistent. So they're notequivalent.
We don't care, this doesn't need to be true. We just need narrators in novels to always be consistent.